First published on StreetCorner on 26 July 2010. Restored from the StreetCorner archive; details reflect the time of writing.
What are we to make of Randwick City Council’s decision to ask the community “whether there should be a ban on smoking in bus shelters in the Randwick City Council area”? Julia Gillard’s plan to hold a citizen’s assembly on emissions trading has been criticised by all sides of politics, as showing leadership failure on climate change. The plan to have 150 members of the public ‘build consensus’ on carbon pricing has been ridiculed as outsourcing of the very decisions we elect politicians to make in the first place.
Is there any difference in the case of Randwick City Council? Instead of the elected representatives of Council making a decision on this issue, a public consultation will take place, with the community asked to complete on-line surveys and to suggest the ways that the smoking ban in bus shelters, if enacted should be enforced. So the community is being asked not only to not only make the decision on whether a smoking ban, but also to come up with the policy on how to administer.
Randwick City Council have set up a site on Bang the Table, a company which charges Councils, Governments and developers for hosting community consultations and are asking the community to register their views on the site.
Randwick City Council’s move highlights an increasing trend at the local government level. Communities have asked Council’s to be more open and transparent for decades, concerned about backroom deals and lack of information. Now, the principles of open government and the benefits of technology are encouraging a movement where “community consultation” is starting to take place on policy issues like carbon pricing (at Federal level) and smoking in bus shelters (at Council level) where the public would normally expect our democratically elected representatives to make the decisions.
Gillard clearly thought a Citizen’s Assembly on carbon pricing would be a popular policy, but she was wrong. The belief that you cannot be criticised if you give the decision back to the people has been debuked. There are many areas of policy, particularly where impact is long-term, that we expect our elected representatives to make informed decisions for us. This is what we elected them to do.
Smoking is a proven health hazard. Research shows approximately 50% of all smokers will die from a smoking related illness. It is not only hazardous to the people who smoke but also to the people who passively inhale the toxins emitted from smokers. Smoking has been banned in airplanes, beaches, pubs, playgrounds and workplaces. Bus shelters provide shelter to public transport users, a large percentage of which are school children and elderly.
Smoking in bus shelters is clearly a health hazard for those who must use the shelter and be subjected to smoke while waiting. The elderly cannot realistically leave the shelter and move away from the bus stop to avoid smoke and nor should they have to. Likewise it is unsafe to ask school children to vacant the shelter to avoid smoke. And all will have no option in a downpour but to inhale if a smoker decides to light up.
So what are we to make of Randwick City Councillors inability to make a decision on this issue? Surely they have the information at their disposal to assess the merits of this issue and they are also likely to more informed than the general public of the ways in which Council could realistically enforce a no smoking ban. Do they genuinely not know which way to go and so are looking to the community for help to assess the merits of a ban? Or are they abrogating from the very role they were elected for?
What are we to make of politicians who ask us to make policy decisions? And to give them implementation strategies? Is this what the community is asking from our politicans? Is this open and transparent government? Or is this a path that undermines the credibility of politicians? If a ban on smoking in bus shelters is an issue that legitimately requires community consultation what are the issues that do not? Or should all Council decisions be given to the community for input? This would signal a return to participatory democracy rather than representative democracy, a return of the power to the people and away from politicians. What is the role of elected representatives if strategic decisions big and small are given back to the people to make?
As we wrestle with these questions, there is another current day dilemma with on-line consultation, and that is the question of who is really being consulted. The advantage of on-line consultation is its low cost and accessibility. However the openness of the consultation depends on the awareness of the survey and relies usually on promotion on the Council website, Council advertising in local newspapers and Council newsletters. Therefore, many in the electorate inevitably remain unaware of the consultation being undertaken but at the same time the vested interests in a consultation are usually aware of the process and can mobilise and skew the results of on-line consultation. Councils, in special circumstances, can send correspondence to every household but this is usually reserved for large decision such as rate increases, not policy like ‘smoking in bus shelters’ where the cost of letterboxing everyone would be prohibitive.
Robust representative samples are also difficult to obtain as age, gender, demographic and suburb information cannot be proven. Age, gender and suburb is often requested but is not verified by any means and socio economic data is not usually collected. Older demographics may be poorly represented and sometimes also younger demographics are underrepresented. Age groups like 18-29 year –olds can be less inclined to participate in local government issues by virtue of other more dominant interests in their life.
In municipalities like Randwick with large public housing communities and elderly residents within these communities the issue of access to internet is a problem and it places an additional burden on already disenfranchised sections of the community if we are asking them to make more effort than everyone else if they wish to have a voice. Often, residents without internet access are asked to visit a library or council chamber to collect physical documents, something this community is the least likely to have the capacity to do.
That doesn’t mean on-line consultation is a bad thing, clearly is it the way of the future but it has to be asked, when is on-line consultation appropriate and if used, when is a representative sample required and how will it be obtained?
Julia Gillard has learnt that the public know which issues legitimately require community consultation and which the public expects our elected representatives to do the job they were elected to do. Is Randwick City Council’s consultation on smoking in bus shelters an example of politicians trying to please everyone or is this an issue that genuinely requires community consultation and policy input?
Randwick City Council residents have until the 8th of September to submit their views and implementation suggestions to Council via
Do you think a ban on smoking in bus shelters is something requires a community consultation process? Or do you think Council has enough information to make an informed decision on behalf of the community on smoking in bus shelters?

















